Wrench [LP] (Evergreen Opaque Vinyl)

Fly Catcher - Wrench [LP] (Evergreen Opaque Vinyl)

Flycatcher-vocalist/guitarist Greg Pease, lead guitarist Justin VanNiekerk, bassist Jack Delle Cava, and drummer Matteo DeBenedetti-have been working toward this moment, and this sound, for a long time.

Formed in TKyear, the New Jersey band have been touring nationally for the past few years, supporting bands like Say Anything, Taking Back Sunday, Slowjoy, Foxing, and Casey. In early 2023, they released their EP Stunt, their first on Will Yip's Memory Music; it followed their 2018 debut LP Other Things, and another full-length the following year, Songs for Strangers. Now, Flycatcher are ready to release their new LP, Wrench, on October 17 on Memory Music.

Wrench is a 10-track collection that came together over a year of writing, demoing, and recording, both on the band's own and with Yip, between stints of intense touring and working other jobs when they got home. When they began writing, Pease says the band intentionally left some space in the songs while heading into Yip's Studio 4; they wanted him to imprint on the songs, breathing his signature weight and drama into them. "I didn't want to overwrite things and be too married to stuff because I wanted to leave room for that studio magic," grins Pease. He and Yip wrote the bridge for the single "Dissolve," which dropped in March 2025, on the fly at Studio 4. (The band previously collaborated with Yip for their 2023 live album, Live at Studio 4.)

The anthemic, loose emo-twang of lead single "Brother," released last year, was one of the first demos that set the tone for the record. After tracking the two singles in early 2024, Flycatcher knew they had found a sound: "Dissolve" has straight-ahead, rolling-boil alt-punk energy a la Oso Oso, and "Brothers" brings country drawl and roots-grunge to the table. They ended up serving as sonic bookends for the record, setting the stage for the rest of Wrench.

With this release, Flycatcher have established a sonic perspective that strips parts from the most exciting sounds of late '90s/early 2000s emo, grunge, pop punk, radio rock, folk, and countryfied indie rock-Pease's reedy, rustic croon could sit overtop a banjo and acoustic guitar, but here, it's put to better, more thrilling use. Many of Wrench's sounds land somewhere in a field bordered by Built to Spill, MJ Lenderman, and fellow Jersey acts Pinegrove and Gates (maybe even, in all the right ways, Nickelback on the chorus of "Brother").

Wrench is colored throughout by the specific regional reality of coming up in New Jersey, but it's also about the universal rollercoaster of your late 20s and early 30s, and the endless mire of thinking about what your life should have been or what it could be or what it was. Do you abandon your ideas of what your life could look like, or do you keep white-knuckling it, fighting to bring them to fruition? "Life just fucking moves," says Pease, "and you have to move with it." To drive the point home, founding drummer Connor Carmelengo decided to step back from the band after tracking Wrench, making it an emotional time-capsule of an era in Flycatcher's life.

The record is also driven by the flawed nature of memories, and what happens when we hold on too tightly to them-or let them go altogether. "We're all just misremembering things all the time," says Pease. "Everything's whatever we want it to be."

Pease, who grew up in New Jersey out near the Delaware Water Gap, is proud that Flycatcher isn't a New York band, or a Brooklyn band, or a Philly band. They're from New Jersey. They formed as a college basement band in New Brunswick, and now all members live in Jersey City. The state, says Pease, has morphed them into "whatever the hell we are." "We're a New Jersey band, and for some people that might mean nothing, but for us and for the people that we came up with, that's kind of everything. There's a reverence that we all have of our upbringing, and there's a reason we haven't left. This place is fucking weird and special and interesting, and it's worth taking a closer look at."

Wrench is out October 24 on Memory Music.
Street Week Focus Track: Man On The Run (Feat. Brianna Collins)
*Focus Track Mood: Feel good indie-twang
*Artist Hometown: New Brunswick, NJ
*Currently Based: New Jersey
*Fans Also Like: MJ Lenderman, Pinegrove, Oso Oso, Slow Joy, and Foxing

*Album / Project Blurb:
Arriving October 24, Wrench takes the worn-in warmth of early emo revivals and melds it with today's twangy sort of indie rock. Think Manchester Orchestra meets MJ Lenderman, or Taking Back Sunday meets Hotline TNT. To capture it, the band--currently made up of guitarist Justin VanNiekerk, bassist Jack Delle Cava, and new drummer Matteo DeBenedetti--returned to Pennsylvania to work with Grammy-nominated producer Will Yip, who is releasing Wrench via his label, Memory Music. Tracklist
Fault Line
Truth
Down
Flood
Wrench
Man On The Run (feat. Brianna Collins)
Dissolve
Watergap
Brother
Superbowl